Orphan Train Discussion Questions

Since Orphan Train was my book club choice for the year, I had to provide the discussion questions. Luckily, there were some provided in the back of the book which I have listed below. We didn’t talk about all of them, but we did hit on most of the main ones. Everyone liked the book overall, but as we began to delve into the questions, a lot of issues arose with certain parts of the book. Everyone liked Vivian’s story a lot better than Molly’s. Molly’s seemed a lot more fake and “stuck in” than Vivian’s and Molly’s native American ancestry was not explored in enough detail.  Everyone also agreed that the author made a poor choice writing Vivian’s child’s adoption into the story. No one thought that was in any way realistic. I really wonder why the author thought that was the right direction to take the story. I think maybe next year I should go back to the sci-fi/fantasy category. I think I did a better job with that one!!

  1. On the surface, Vivian’s and Molly’s lives couldn’t be more different, but in what ways are their stories similar?
  2. In the prologue, Vivian mentions that her “true love” died when she was twenty-three, but she doesn’t mention the other big secret in the book. Why not?
  3. Why hasn’t Vivian ever shared her story with anyone? Why does she tell it now?
  4. What role does Vivian’s grandmother play in her life? How does the reader’s perception of her shift as the story unfolds?
  5. Why does Vivian seem unable to get rid of the boxes in her attic?
  6. In Women of the Dawn, a nonfiction book about the lives of four Wabanaki Indians that is excerpted in the epigraph, Bunny McBride writes: “In portaging from one river to another, Wabanakis had to carry their canoes and all other possessions. Everyone knew the value of traveling light and understood that it required leaving some things behind. Nothing encumbered movement more than fear, which was often the most difficult burden to surrender. How does the concept of portaging reverberate throughout this novel? What fears hamper Vivian’s progress? Molly’s?
  7. Vivian’s name changes several times over the course of the novel—from Niamh Power to Dorothy Nielsen to Vivian Daly. How are these changes significant for her? How does each name represent a different phase of her life?
  8. What significance, if any, does Molly Ayer’s name have?
  9. How did Vivian’s first-person account of her youth and the present-day story from Molly’s third-person-limited perspective work together? Did you prefer one story to the other? Did the juxtaposition reveal things that might not have emerged in a traditional narrative?
  10. In what ways, large or small, does Molly have an impact on Vivian’s life? How does Vivian have an impact on Molly’s?
  11. What does Vivian mean when she says, “I believe in ghosts”?
  12. When Vivian finally shares the truth about the birth of her daughter and her decision to put May up for adoption, she tells Molly that she was “selfish” and “afraid”. But Molly defends her and affirms Vivian’s choice. How did you perceive Vivian’s decision? Were you surprised she sent her own child to be adopted after her own experiences with the Children’s Aid Society?
  13. When the children are presented to audiences of potential caretakers, the Children’s Aid Society explains that adoptive families are responsible for the child’s religious upbringing. What role does religion play in this novel? How do Molly and Vivian each view God?
  14. When Vivian and Dutchy are reunited, Vivian remarks, “However hard I try, I will always feel alien and strange. And now I’ve stumbled on a fellow outsider, one who speaks my language without saying a word.” How is this also true for her friendship with Molly?
  15. When Vivian goes to live with the Byrnes, Fanny offers her food and advises, “You got to learn to take what people are willing to give.” In what ways is this good advice for both Vivian and Molly? And in contrast, what are some instances when their independence helped them?
  16. Molly is enthusiastic about Vivian’s reunion with her daughter, but makes no further efforts to see her own mother. Why is she unwilling (or unable) to effect a reunion in her own family? Do you think she will someday?
  17. Vivian’s claddagh cross is mentioned often throughout the story. What is its significance? How does its meaning change or deepen over the course of Vivian’s life?

Leave a comment

Filed under Book Club, Book Review

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s